Now I was seeing a lot of people on Discord dogpiling on AOR as a shit genre, and crapping on it, and one person said "anybody who did prog rock and went on to make AOR in the 80s deserves to be shot on site". That's paraphrasing, but my favorite band, Asia, came to mind. I tried to explain why I like AOR to them. I don't know if I got through, but I am used to AOR getting crapped on, and my own tastes being opposite most other people's. I've heard every insult you can dish towards AOR, such as MOR (middle of the road) etc. However I don't think I could have fully explained the truth behind Asia and the music beyond whatever simple conversation I had.
Yes was a band also at the end of it's rope by this time. Guitarist Steve Howe wanted to take the band in an increasingly more hard rock direction, as he had been seeking to make more direct rockers for a long time. This in part is what made Anderson and Wakeman leave. Some of this can be felt on stuff like "Machine Messiah", "Does it Really Happen" and "Tempus Fugit", though a lot of their progressive leanings were still present. Following the Drama tour Horn was let go, and Chris Squire and Alan White would leave soon after. Howe and the then keyboardist Geoff Downes had declined to continue Yes and they split up. Wetton had tried starting a project with Rick Wakeman and Carl Palmer, but Wakeman didn't see eye to eye musically with Wetton and the project was shelved. John Kalodner had seen Wetton struggling to get a new project together, due to his wanting to work with other prog musicians, but his growing distaste for prog rock made that an impossiblity. He introduced Wetton to Steve Howe who was feeling similarly to him. The two began writing and auditioning musicians. Carl Palmer auditioned at Wetton's suggestion because the two had tried starting supergroups before but failed. Palmer himself was a man who contributed a lot more rockers or straightforward stuff to ELP. Just look at "Tank", "L.A. Nights" and "New Orleans". Once Palmer passed they auditioned keyboard players, including Electric Light Orchestra's Richard Tandy. However for keyboard players they settled on Geoff Downes at Howe's request. Downes had a background in pop rock and synthpop, and actually turned out to get along so well with John Wetton that the two's songwriting partnership would become the backbone of the band, even though Wetton had written already written almost half an album's worth of songs with Howe. Wetton also got former Queen engineer Mike Stone (best known for producing Journey's album Escape) to produce, having been impressed with his prior work and meeting him at a party. With how many times Wetton tried to get this project going in the past it is clear that it was a huge passion project for him.
Now I hear people call this a sell out album or something engineered to make money, but that isn't true. Wetton has stated several times it was an uphill battle getting the album released. Geffen records said their wasn't a viable single, the band's logo (designed by Yes album artist Roger Dean) was illegible, the album artwork (also by Roger Dean) would be hard to find in a record store and not stand out, the music was something they couldn't market. At some point it seemed like the album may not get released or a push. Wetton said this lowered his expectations greatly as some people said they have too many keyboards and others said they need to tone down prog guitar elements in the music. That was until the lead single came out and become one of the most iconic hits of the entire decade. Everything changed. It sold 10 million copies, is one of a small handful of albums to have never been out of print ever, and it's success shaped mainstream rock of the 80s. I've heard people say so much bad things about this album. It is trash, Carl Palmer is wasted playing crap any 2 bit drummer could play, the album is over produced, the songwriting and musicianship is weak and something anyone could do, the album sounds like it was made by a computer, it's shallow and meaningless. I am here to debunk some of these criticisms at Asia's debut album and hopefully sell you on it by going through these songs track by track.
The album opens with "Heat of the Moment". The song was originally a country song in 6/8 John wrote as an apology to the girl he would eventually marry. When presented to Geoff Downes they changed the verses to make it a grand pop rock song with a standard time signature. Aside from being a total earworm brought to life with Wetton's soulful vocal performance, Carl Palmer's drum fills, and Steve Howe's guitar riff hooking the listener in, it is intentionally placed here at the beginning to serve a few purposes. One, to attract people who heard the hit song on the radio and bought the album for it. Two, to scare off prog rock elitists who may have tried to listen to this band assuming it to be some epic prog rock thing, And three, it appeased the record label, which unfortunately has the final say. It's not even the best song here, but it is a strong opener. Next song and second single "Only Time Will Tell" is like a lot of songs here is a super personal song Wetton had written awhile before the album was being worked on. It starts with keyboard riff by Downes, then lead into some rocking guitar by Howe with some cowbell form Palmer and crunchy bass playing from Wetton. In the verses we have some of that keyboard playing keeping the song going with some hi hat by Palmer before moving on to thumping bassline from Wetton driving the song into an anthemic chorus. You may notice Howe isn't much of a leading factor in this song aside from contributing to some bits leading into the next part of the song, as well as a call and response in the verses. I love this call and response, and I think it does good showing off Howe and Downes backing vocals. This makes sense it is a Wetton and Downes composition. Steve Howe and Geoff Downes get to do some backing vocals here that just sound lovely. I can't not love his song.
"Sole Survivor" is the the third single and another Wetton and Downes composition. I LOVE the opening in "Soul Survivor". It is super ballsy to make the listener wait through some technical showmanship leading to the song itself in one of your big singles. Aside from me relating to the lyrics here to an extreme degree, Wetton's vocals are just amazing. The bass line and drums driving the song forward in the verses is wonderful. The guitar is used where it is needed, and they keyboards know when to take a backseat. about two minutes and fourty seconds in we get this section that is mostly keyboards as the song stops. It builds and builds to this cool section where the guitar and keyboards really get to show off and the drums and bass just do there thing. Then verse 3 where John delivers one of the most elegantly delivered fuck you's in music with the line "and from the wreckage I will arise and cast the ashes back in their eyes". Knowing the exact kind of feeling he is talking about and having been a scenario like that myself makes hearing that line super satisfying to me. The following lyrics to are great. Then we end on an awesome chorus and a fade out.
"One Step Closer" is a song Wetton cowrote with Howe, which is obvious because the two's voices are singing together to create a harmony throughout most of the song. This gives the vocals here a unique sound. The verses are driven by the keyboards and bass, but we have this earworm of a chorus that has been unable to leave my head for pretty much my entire life. The guitar solo is short and sweet, and the drums are great too. It's actually one of the most simple songs here. However "Time Again" is where things get serious. This is the one song credited to all 4 band members It starts with this guitar riff amplified by the bass and keyboards as it goes on and some drums coming in as it ends, then some harmonies by Wetton. A gong is sounded off by Palmer as the riff comes in, now with Carl Palmer's drums helping to build up the riff this time. Then with a symbol crash we get John's thumping bassline driving the song with leads from the guitar and keyboards adding all the flary melody to it. We don't get vocals until a minute and fourteen seconds into the song. Again a sort of call and response between Wetton and the guitar in the verses while his bass rives it forward. Carl Palmer's drums here are just awesome, I love them. The way it leads into the solo is just incredible. Wetton's vocals are of course incredible. I love how it ends the same way we began, just awesome.
Wetton and Downes' "Wildest Dreams" is a strangely political song. The song has this opening with the keyboards, drums and bass playing the same thing until about 30 seconds in. The first verse are mostly vocals and keyboard with some light drums, but then pre chorus comes in. The song builds up to the chorus, which is the song name with some awesome harmonies. Then the second verse, we get some frequent guitar and keyboards, then the prechorus and the song hanging on some keyboard for a bit before going to the chorus, which has more going on than before. Then the opening with a guitar solo over it. This leads into a bridge section where the drums and guitar help build to the third verse. Then the chorus, even bigger than before. Following this the opening of the song, with a key change and a short drum solo from Carl Palmer. A repeat of the bridge section and the keyboards giving us a nice outro. The fact that they crammed all these details and sections into a five minute song is incredible, and is masterfully done.
I absolutely love "Without You", a song written by Wetton and Howe, because it is a very subversive ballad. It's a pretty standard sounding ballad. drums and keyboards lead through an ambient intro, then the verses, lead by Wetton's bass and the drums. After a sort of chorus we have verse 2. Then after the chorus we get a some keyboard, bass and drums leading us into a bridge. About two and a half minutes into the song the bridge transitions to what sounds like a completely different song, with a completely different speed and with a new melody being played by the keyboards and the guitar. Then we build up to this new section where the instruments all play a altered version of the instrumental from the verses, but with Howe giving an absolutely majestic guitar riff and some cool sounds from the keyboards. Then Howe playing a Koto (Japanese string instrument) and leading us back into another verse. We have the final chorus and then the song goes into an outro section that once again sounds like it comes from a different song. I love it because you think it will be a typical ballad, but then it hits you with these parts that sound almost like they are from different songs, but they are woven in organically.
I love "Cutting It Fine". It is a rocker that also goes in a completely different direction than you think it will. starts with typical acoustic intro from Howe but then goes to the main guitar riff and a verse section lead by Wetton's bass. Wetton delivers his lines with this attitude. After each verse we have the awesome guitar riff by Howe, a top 20 favorite guitar riff of mine. Then we build to a section after the second verse dominated by keyboard and guitar. The backing vocals with Howe and Downes are cool, especially when Downes does them with a vocoder. After the third verse is another keyboard section and it just stops. The you have this piano section that transitions to synths with this marching drum beat. the synths build and build with the drums and then it just fades. I apologize to all of you narrow minded fools who say this whole album sounds like it was tailor made for radio play, because "Cutting It Fine" could not make into the radio like this, and "Without You" probably wouldn't have been able to either.
Album closer "Here Comes the Feeling" is another Wetton and Howe composition. Opening with a main keyboard riff from Downes and cowbell from Palmer, then the main drums and some lead guitar with the keyboard riff. The verse sections start empty with just Wetton and the synths until the bass and drums kick in. Palme's drumming is simple but effective. I love the build up to that chorus, and the chorus itself is great. We have a standard verse with even more build up to that chorus, then a keyboard solo after the chorus. Then a nice guitar solo leading to our next verse. The verse chorus is what you expect by this point, but then we rehash the opening of the song, this time with the guitar, yet another chorus and then more of the opening, just with a focus on the guitar, then it ends.
However like most albums, Asia's debut had more stuff than there was room for. A subdued instrumental piece John wrote called "Deya" was rehearsed, but never made it on the album, and a Wetton Howe composition called "Ride Easy" was recorded, but didn't make it, leaving it resorted to a B side. "Ride Easy" has this cool intro leading to an ambient verse lead by ambient synths and sparse guitar until the rest of the instruments kick in half way leading to a great chorus. It's standard verse chorus from here, but the added instrumentation as it progresses is nice and the bridge section is wonderful. Then after another verse and chorus we have a wonderful guitar solo by Howe and fade out. It's not a particularly impressive, but John lamented it not making it onto the album because it is one of his favorite Asia songs, and I like it, so I felt I had to mention it.
Asia's debut is not pure AOR schlock like most people will lead you to believe, but rather it combines the prog sensibilities of many of the musicians involved and adds a proggressive flare and style to these fairly straight forward rock songs. Side 2 of the album is proof enough, and some songs on side 1 like Time Again also prove it. Yeah, it's not Yes or King Crimson, but it's not trying to be either. The musicians involved were people who watched the influential prog bands they were in basically implode and were burnt out on that type of music. Carl Palmer was offered to do an ELP reunion but chose to stay in Asia, which should tell you something. I'd best describe a lot of songs from Asia's debut as kind of like how Aaron Copeland described ELP's version of "Fanfare for the Common Man". It starts and exactly like how you expect, but it's the oddities and showmanship offered in between the middle and after the end that make it stand out.
I'm not going to track by track every single Asia album, but I want to mention more history and the notable stuff in Wetton's stints with the band to help prove my point. So following the debut being one of the biggest rock albums of that decade the label demanded a follow up before any of the band members were ready. Conflict would arise between Wetton and Howe over who was responsible for the band's explosive success. Wetton claimed he was because he had writing credit on every song, sang lead, and was the guy who helped pen the explosive mega hit that propelled them to stardom in the first place. Howe claimed he was because he cowrote most of the progressive and interesting songs, as well as being the one who suggested hiring Downes, who cowrote the rest of the debut with Wetton. Both had their points, but it led to a rift in Wetton and Howe's songwriting partnership. This would strain would be worsened when Geffen records requested Wetton and Downes write most the album because the singles from the debut were all their compositions. Howe contributed the instrumental "Masquerade", which would later be reworked into an entirely acoustic guitar based song and released on Yes's Union album, where he would be nominated for a Grammy for best rock instrumental performance. Howe's original band version recorded with Asia didn't make the cut and would go unreleased for decades. Howe's other contribution was "Barren Land", a song about mistreatment of Native Americans, until he was convinced to rewrite the lyric's by John Kalodner because Kalodner feared the lyrics would be controversial. Wetton contributed the song "The Smile Has Left Your Eyes", originally an almost six minute ballad with a much more progressive structure. However it was shortened to 3 minutes (you can hear some notable cuts in this version). You can hear this original masterful version on the Symphonia live album to get an idea what it originally sounded like, albeit in a live setting.
When the album was finished the record label refused to release it because it didn't have a hit single. Wetton and Downes quickly wrote "Don't Cry", which disappointed everyone with it's commercial sound. The band needed to rush out the album, but technical difficulties made mastering hard, and the end result was a wall of sound type production. The band demanded a remix to give it a less polished, less thick and less commercial sound, but that didn't change much. They wanted to spend more time fixing it, but the deadline was close and concert dates were scheduled, so they had to settle. This is the kind of album people accuse the debut of being. This right here is your pure AOR with blatant commercial sensibilities. However this album still has plenty of great moments, and the band would get their revenge in the form of a music video for "Don't Cry" that required a six figure budget for all the grand sets they used.
I also want to give attention to "Daylight" and "Lyin' To Yourself". I love both these songs and think "Lyin' to Yourself" in particular should have been on the album. As you can imagine I also wish Howe didn't change the lyrics.
After Geffen did squat to promote the album the band broke up. Downes and Wetton wrote new songs for a new lineup of Asia with Thin Lizzy guitarist Scott Gorham, but those plans fell through when the only place they could get a contract was in Japan. (these songs were released as an album in 2002) The Astra lineup reunited for a tour and a best of with new material. While I love all the new songs featured, especially the ambient "Am I in Love?" the album sold close to a million but still wasn't enough to convince John or Mandy to stay. The two left to be replaced by Roger Daltry's bassist and backing vocalist John Payne and future Savatage guitarist Al Pitrelli, as well as a returning Steve Howe.
Okay so those second and third albums weren't quite as impressive as the debut, so I'll fast forward to where things get interesting here in a bit. First I wanted to highlight what John considers his magnum opus. "Battle Lines" is often maligned because people see names like Robert Fripp and Simon Phillips in the liner notes and expect something epic, only to get disappointed. John said "Battle Lines" was an extremely personal album of songs he was scared of releasing because of just how personal they were. So he waited until it was prime time for a solo album, and he rewrote them with Bob Marlette. The cold reception to Asia and later this album is a big part of what would lead John into a downward spiral in terms of how he how he lived and would lead to the decline in his health that followed. Every time he would be happy with a project it always seemed people who knew him as a prog rock legend would crap on it for being basically AOR or pop rock. John released an album where on nearly every song he was airing out super personal emotions and feelings, and people just decided it was bad. I urge you to listen to Battle Lines, and see it not as a solo album by a prog rock legend, but as a personal and deeply moving experience for John in the form of music. How can anyone listen to the ode to his mother "Hold Me Now", a heartbreaking glimpse into his past, and then just write it off as schlock?
Wetton has other solo albums too, but I'll gloss over those, as this is an an article about Asia. Wetton remained on good terms with Downes and Palmer. He formed Quango as a successor to Asia, featuring himself on bass and vocals, Palmer on drums, John Young on keyboards and Dave Kilminster on guitar. The band was met with issues on the outset and were not gaining any momentum, leading to a breakup after a single live album. Later Downes contributed two songs to one of Wetton's "Rock of Faith" album and the two started writing together again. They then started the Icon project. While making a seventh Asia album with John Payne, Downes and Wetton met up with Howe and Palmer, and the four reconnected after years in a way they hadn't in a long time. John Payne, Guthrie Govan and Jay Schellen (who is actually the current Yes drummer as of writing this) were sacked and the original lineup was back together. Asia rose like a phoenix from the ashes, and that was the inspiration behind the new album's name, and in my opinion a candidate for their best album, and I will track by track for that reason.
"Alibis" was written by all the band members. It's a pleasant song driven by bass and drums with nice keyboard melodies over it. The song is just pleasant. After the second chorus we get a guitar solo. The we go into verse 3 and chorus 3. Then a trade off between they keyboards and guitar in a solo section before chorus 4. After the song just stops and we get an acoustic guitar riff from Howe and some percussion from Palmer, seeing him utilize parts of his kit he hasn't used on an Asia album before. Then a electric guitar solo and a keyboard riff from Downes taking us into the fade out. Yeah... real arena rock schlock am I right? Sorry if I am coming off like I am trying to start I fight I am not. "I Will Remember You" is a beautiful stripped down ballad remembering a lost loved one, which never fails to hit me in the feels. Palmer's drums here are nice, and the guitar solo near the end with Wetton's harmonies is excellent. "Shadow of a Doubt" is a fantastic pop rock song with some nice acoustic guitar and drumming in the verses giving it this gentle nature, then an electric chorus with a energetic chorus with this nice sense of momentum. The song has a guitar solo in the middle that is nice and leads to some cool guitar leads in the final chorus, but nothing too special.
"Parallel Worlds/Vortex/Deya" is incredible. It starts with a wonderful stripped down ballad where Wetton is singing his heart out. The keyboards and guitar. The bass playing here is nice too. About two and a half minutes in it ends and we get to "Vortex". Acoustic guitar and piano guide us to the main melody. Then Carl Palmer gives us some fast double kick drum, and Howe leads us with some great guitar playing. The synths are doing some great stuff here too. Palmer accentuates every new part very well with his drumming. 4 minutes in he starts using symbols frequently and then gives us a drum roll and he combines that with the double kick part before playing the double kick part with the snare and using all the toms on his kit with the symbols in addition to it. He gives us an epic drum roll and then with a hit of one of his gongs it ends and we get to "Deya", the instrumental John rehearsed during the sessions for their debut. It is driven mostly by acoustic guitar, but the drums come in and the synths provide nice flourishes to add to the ambiance. Palmer does some nice stuff on the drums leading to some soloing from Howe. The songs ends with some wonderful acoustic from Howe. Easily the most progressive piece Asia has done. Play this for some prog snob who has crapped on this band as being cheesy arena rock garbage and watch their cocky smirk turn into a scowl.
"Wish I'd Known All Along" is a Howe solo composition. I love the intro, especially Palmer's percussion and Wetton's vocals. The verses do a very nice call and response between the vocals and keyboards. The chorus is great too. After the second chorus we have a guitar solo from Howe leading us to an interesting bridge section where the song shifts gears completely. Then a keyboard solo over the instrumentation from the verse. (kind of like what they did in "Without You") After another chorus we have a wonderful outro and it ends. "Orchard of Mines" is a cover of a song by epic music band Globus. Their cover is pretty straight forward, but made to accommodate a more restrained production and the fact that Asia is a four piece. This is a very weird choice of song to cover, but it works. The band does a great job here. A real highlight for me. "Over and Over Again" is another Howe solo composition. Wetton shines here, and the song itself is solid. Howe's solo here after the first chorus is wonderful. Then a nice electric guitar solo follows later after some once again amazing vocals from Wetton. The last minute is just instrumental. Howe showing off on the guitar and some great work with the synths.
Lastly is Wetton's most personal Asia song. During the 90s after the mediocre reception to Battle Lines Wetton was drinking a lot and spiraling out of control. (Getting out of this cycle was why there was the big gap between the release of his solo albums "Archangel" and "Sinister") His health took a dive and he needed open heart surgery. His doctor told there is a small chance he will die during it, and Wetton came to grips with the thought that he may not be alive the next day. So he got really reflective and had a new outlook on life he never had before, and it had positively influenced the way he lived and thought. No regrets, live everyday like it is your last because it just might be. A beautiful message I hardcore relate to, and one that I think everyone can learn from. Wetton wrote "Extraordinary Life" to share that philosophy and mind set with the world. The intro is wonderful, but also reminds me of the soundtrack of "Pikmin 2". A minute in the song really gets going. Wetton's vocals are great, and the chorus section is just wonderful. 3 minutes in we get a nice bridge section where the song switches gears and comes to a crawl, before going to another upbeat chorus. Howe gives us a nice solo, and we end with one final chorus.
Phoenix was polarizing when it came out. Some said the band matured, and this album is a beautiful next step that showed this band had a lot to offer, or that their time away brought something new to the table. However other critics hated it, saying the catchiness or edge of the first couple albums was gone and there was no song worthy of standing next to "Heat of the Moment" or "Only Time Will Tell". Me, the world's biggest Asia fan, am just gonna say it. Phoenix is the best Asia album. It does so much interesting stuff that the first couple albums just didn't, as well as taking notes on what made the debut so great and carrying over many of those elements. They expanded upon the debut with a more mature and laid back follow up that I think stands as their best work.
Following Phoenix and the successful tour for it, they made "Omega" with producer Mike Paxman, which to me is just okay. Very disappointing as a follow up to Phoenix. Opening track "Finger on the Trigger" is a rerecording of a song from second album by Downes and Wetton's Icon side project. It's rerecorded here as a more raw and hard edged rocker, and it is better, and a solid track but nothing special aside from Wetton saying "balls" in the context of genitals in one part of the song. "Through My Veins" is an excellent slow and groove oriented track penned by Howe and Wetton. "Holy War" is excellent. It builds up to the first verse with the keyboards and has this great sense of momentum in the verses. The chorus is nice and song is well done. The song kind of stops 3 minutes in so Palmer can have an awesome drum solo. Then the song carries on like normal after that. I love Palmer getting a chance to shine here. As cheesy as they are I have a soft spot for "Listen Children" and "End of the World". Wetton an Howe's other collaboration "Light the Way" is a great quick tempo rock song with nice keyboard playing, especially a section in the middle where the plays this interesting melody leading to a guitar solo. After another chorus we just get another solo as the song ends. I am only mentioning "Emily" because it is a pretty bad song and is about Wetton falling in love with a Lesbian. Also in Japan this song was replaced with the Japan exclusive song "Drop a Stone", a writing collaboration between all the band members, which is a fun groovy and almost southern sounding song.
"Faithful" started life as a power ballad until John Wetton requested they strip it down to avoid it being stupidly cheesy. It is like this until three minutes in when suddenly we get a fast rock instrumental version of the chorus, with Howe playing the vocal melody on the guitar. Wetton gives us some vocals and then Howe comes in with guitar solo over some great drumming by Palmer. The song then becomes this upbeat rocker with the same melodies and such as before. Then it ends with just Wetton and some piano. "I Know How You Feel" is a standard bass driven song with some keyboards from Downes helping to carry it. Then a keyboard section about two minutes and fifty seconds in with Wetton saying "I Know" gently. Then a beautiful acoustic guitar solo form Howe. "Face on the Bridge" was the lead single and it is great. Wetton's bass drives the song forward and it is wonderful. Nothing to special going on aside from the instrumentation going pretty hard near the end Howe soloing. "Al Gatta Nero" is an undeniably earworm, but not much of interest is done here. "Judas" is another Howe, Wetton and Downes track. Once again nothing too special done, but it is a great more straight forward rock song. the main riff, the verses and the catchy chorus, as well as the keyboard playing in the outro. "Ghost of a Chance" starts as a boring mostly acoustic ballad, typical stuff. Then half way through all the electric instruments come in and the keyboards playing the vocal melody from before sounds amazing. Then the guitar does it. The whole vibe and atmosphere of this last half of the song really is what makes it. when Wetton comes in at the end to deliver the final verse, it feels so earned and incredible.
"XXX" was the last album to feature Steve Howe, who would say that with Yes becoming a big touring entity again during the early 2010s, he was unable to keep up with both bands, and chose Yes. They sought guitar GOAT Paul Gilbert, who was too busy and recommended guitarist Sam Coulson, who was famous for his videos of him playing on YouTube, leading to him playing on Asia's final album Gravitas, which kept up with being decently progressive.
I'm not saying Asia is some secret treasure of progressive rock, but that people are wrong about them. So many people waste time dogging on this band like they have no right to even exist. Don't blame this band as a sell out project engineered to sell records, blame yourself for being narrowminded and unwilling to just let John Wetton's passion project be. So many great songs, so much interesting musicianship and things done. If you can't look past something that isn't some big obvious ten minute prog epic to see talented musicianship and interesting things being done musically, it's your own problem. Regardless of whether or not you give this band a second chance, I wanted to get this of my chest. I hope you at least got some enjoyment out of this article and especially hope you decided to reconsider your stance on Asia or even check them out if you haven't already. If you want a follow up where I talk about the John Payne era and that whole can of worms please comment or contact me and let me know.